http://www.nt.armstrong.edu/METAPHOR.htm
RHETORIC (ENGLISH 5730 U/G)
DEFINITIONS
(Gk. "carrying from one place to another") A figure of speech in which one
thing is described in terms of another. The basic figure in poetry. A
comparison is usually implicit; whereas in simile it is explicit.
(J. A. Cuddon, Dictionary of Literary Terms, 3rd ed., 1991)
Where simile asserts the likeness of one thing to another, metaphor
asserts their identity. Usually, though not always, something relatively abstract is
identified with something relatively concrete, making it more vivid or accessible.
Since the mind seems better able to understand a new concept through concrete illustration
than abstract explanation, the language is full of dead metaphors, in which illustration
has been fully absorbed into concept. Metaphor itself (literally
"a carrying over") is one, and so are "abstract" [ML, "to drag
away, divert"] and explanation [L., "to smooth out, make
intelligible"]. . . . The terms commonly used nowadays for the
figurative or concrete element of a metaphor and its literal or conceptual element are
those suggested by I. A. Richards: vehicle and tenor. In a good
metaphor the two should have enough in common to avoid absurdity while being different
enough for the vehicle to enrich the tenor as well as illustrating it. . . .
As might be expected, creative literature uses more live metaphors than ordinary
language does. These are distinguished from dead metaphors by the the fact that the
figurative element has not been absorbed into the conceptual, but it should be emphasized
that the specific images conveyed (which may differ somewhat from reader to reader anyway)
are less important than the vehicle's ability to make the idea in the tenor powerfully
connotative.
(Ian Ousby, ed., The Cambridge Guide to Literature in English, 1988)
An analogy identifying one object with another and ascribing to the first object
one or more of the qualities of the second. . . . The tenor is the
idea being expressed or the subject of the comparison; the vehicle is the image
by which this idea is conveyed or the subject communicated. . . . Aristotle
praised the metaphor as "the greatest thing by far" for poets--a
sentiment seconded by Ezra Pound, who endorsed Aristotle's calling apt metaphor
"the hallmark of genius"--and saw it as the product of their insight, which
permitted them to find the similarities in seemingly dissimilar things. . . .
According to a fairly ingenuous notion of language, abstractions can be treated only in
terms that are not abstract, presumably because the primitive mind cannot handle
abstractions. But no evidence establishes the existence of any such limitations.
To presume that any human being has to have a grasp of physical "pulling
away" before being able to grasp an abstract "abstraction" is little more
than bigotry.
(Harmon & Holman, A Handbook to Literature, 2000)
Metaphors are necessary not only to our conceptual structure of everyday
experience, but also to the structure of theories across academic disciplines.
Theorists often begin with analogy, a perceived resemblance between a thing as yet not
identified and another known, familiar thing. Researchers then pursue the analogy to
see how far the resemblances between two phenomena can be extended. This pursuit is
a primary way theories are tested, advanced, or replaced by others. Of the sciences,
Kenneth Burke says, "Whole works of scientific research, even entire schools, are
hardly more than the patient repetition, in all its ramifications, of a fertile
metaphor." Two examples from physics are black holes and chaos, both of which
are metaphors that have seized the imagination of theorists in other domains of knowledge,
such as business, political science, and literature, and have influenced the direction of
study in these secondary fields. The first phrase, black hole, is, in fact, now so
popularized that it is even used metaphorically to express fear of our fate and that of
the universe, or to explain the sudden and complete disappearance of anything lost--from a
dream to a weekend to a book of stamps.
(Dona J. Hickey, Figures of Thought for College Writers, 1999)